Dear Frank Ackland,
Thank you for your reply February 23rd. I have consulted with my investors and they advise against making the information public. But there are options I am considering. One of them could be you sign an NDA because you cannot use the understanding, which I am pretty sure you can’t and have no need of, then using your discretion inform Andrea that the method seems viable with the explanation, the maths and geometry. This is something I am only considering but of course I realize Andrea does not want to sign an NDA, neither would I, as I too would prefer to develop the method myself and who’s to say maybe he will but without knowing the contents of an NDA I do not see how someone can make such an important decision. As I have previously stated nothing gained nothing lost. I do not need any information from Andrea i.e. what the E Cat consists of as I already have a very good idea. All I want to do is put his E Cat into a self sustaining mode so as to produce a constant supply of electricity. Who knows maybe he will achieve success next week, next year or at some future date but there are many people as myself who want this technology to succeed. Obviously, the very last resort will be to ask me how. I should also add that what originally stirred my interest was the remark made by Prof regarding a worldwide organization that I presume is the same one that I was involved with not too long ago. My technology is also controversial and was described as one before its time. Maybe its time has come.
Regards Eric Ashworth.
Sture Andreasson:
I am not yet able to tell when exactly will be made the presentation, but surely it will also be streamed in internet probably live.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Donald G. Chandler:
Before talking of neutrons, I wish I could be sure to know well electrons. I prefer not to put the cart ahead of the horses.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Discussion of particle asymmetry here. Neutrons, not electrons, in this case, but maybe still of interest.
“Neutrons are believed to be slightly asymmetrical in shape, being slightly positive at one end and slightly negative at the other — a bit like the electrical equivalent of a bar magnet. “
Will the demonstration start in Stockholm during mars, and then going on several weeks?
Can we see the start at internet, and then follow the demonstration there?
Lotr Mileikowsky:
Thank you for your suggestion.
Answer: it is possible to concentrate the control systems for more Ecats into one control system to be designed on the base of the modules’ combined power.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
PlasmaFan:
Thank you for the information. My answer is: no.
When you see theories that have no link with my paper http://www.researchgate.net/publication/330601653_E-Cat_SK_and_long_range_particle_interactions
it is very difficult it has to do with the plasma of the E-Cat SK or SKL, because in this paper we put all the possible leads to a theoretical explication of the effect obtained by the Ecat.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Does using diamond coated electrodes that can be embedded with hydrogen atoms from the plasma to produce a Negative Electron Affinity improve the performance of your plasma based E-Cats?
I wondered if you knew that Ulrich Kranz is the CEO of Canoo, a manufacturer of very advanced electric vehicles, expecting to launch leasing of EVs next year.
as computer control module for sure play role in manufacturing price and end price for customers, I have such query:
Every one E-Cat SKL module need own one electronic control module or is it posssible to control for example 4 E-Cat SKLs with 4 core ARM CPU control module?
For future presentation style of E-Cat SKL I propose such old idea (beside the more scientific water shower calorimetry):
E-Cat SKL powering aeromodeller grade electromotor equipped with aeromodeller propeller, behind it a small pole with a few fluttering ribbons in airflow. This whole set on cart with wheels as proof there is no hidden cables from ground.
Regarding your answer “H=F” to Kranz, I’m afraid that you are 21% short of the power output required to get a 5th slot for your picture on top of Dr Brown’s fireplace insert :
In your paper you have explained theoretical mechanisms, in future papers you may update and expand on these mechanisms based on results of E-Cat testing. Is it possible in future papers that you can make predictions that could be detected or suggest specific tests that interested physicists can construct without using E-Cat technology that would aid in the conformation of theory.
A – Is it possible to make a 1 MW power station from a large number of ECAT SKl units?
B – Is it possible to combine 1 MW ECAT SKL power stations to larger units with the Power of C-F?
C – 100 MW?
D – 300 MW?
E – 500 MW?
F – 1000 MW?
G – Ort is has you planned to create a SKL given turbine for such amounts?
H – What will be the largest power of combined ECAT SKL
Mr Andrea Rossi,
in the video in http://www.ecatskdemo.com
the plasma appears to be composed by different zones with different characteristics: are you extracting electricity separately from different zones ?
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi,
Thank you for your publication http://www.researchgate.net/publication/330601653_E-Cat_SK_and_long_range_particle_interactions
wherein appears clearly how you obtain a gain of energy without necessity of nuclear reactions, entering in a field in which the second principle of thermodynamic is not applicable, as well as it is not applicable in the field of the catalyzers.
All the best,
CC
Sarah Waldhof:
You read very superficially what I write. If you read with a minimum of intelligence, you can see that I wrote that the noise from the plasma cannot be heard directly by the ears, but can be heard with a stethoscope. When I wrote “never” answering your first comment, I was talking of acoustic pollution, as your first comment was clearly intending, not of stethoscopes. After the second comment of you, it appears a bit malicious that you did not specify in your first comment “can the noise from the plasma be heard by a stethoscope ?”: in this case the answer would have been “yes”.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dr. Rossi,
Would it be possible for the independent tester(s) to provide a report for the ECat-SKL presentation certifying that the device operated for (X) weeks, producing (Y) KWH of electricity while consuming (Z) KWH of electricity (where (Z) could be zero)?
Sarah Waldhof:
The plasma. It makes sounds that have a too low level of decibells to be heared directly by ears, but with stethoscope we can receive important information.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Kranz:
Thank you for your insight.
The numbers you give are a supposition. The real numbers will be given during the presentation.
Answers:
A- this depends from the situations
B- I do not know
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Helsinki city has just launched a global competition called the Helsinki Energy Challenge. The winning proposal will be given one million euro prize.
Here is some introduction text copied from the Helsinki Energy Challenge web site https://energychallenge.hel.fi/
—————–
Currently, more than half of the city’s heat is produced with coal. In order to achieve carbon-neutrality, we need radically new solutions to meet Helsinki’s heat demand. And we are not alone. To fight climate change, sustainable heating solutions are needed in cities all over the world. Heating not just beyond coal, but also beyond burning biomass.
That is why we are launching the Helsinki Energy Challenge.
A global one-million-euro challenge competition to answer the question: How can we decarbonise the heating of Helsinki, using as little biomass as possible?
—————–
I think your company could make the winning proposal.
It is now over 9 years since you introduced the E-Cat, the Energy Catalyzer, in your current devices is there still something with a catalytic function or is the name catalyzer now just part of the E-Cat history.
given the ECAT SKL has a volume of 10*10*7 cm and a power of 0,7 kWel and 0,3 kWth.
The combination of an ECAT SKL with an infrared heater panel with 700 W power consumption could a product for heating homes and offices. The 300 Wth would be an advantage.
The ECAT SKL could mounted backside the panel with the AI controller and a starter battery.
Despite the cost for electricity for the panel, in Germany and Austria are old and new houses are changing their oil/gas heating to infrared heater panels.
An advantage is the fast heating up of the panels and the good ability to control them.
Sure a prerequisite to use the ECAT SKL, is a certification for domestic use.
My questions:
A – Is it possible to mount an ECAT SKL backside the panel with the AI controller and a starter battery?
B – How long will it last to get a certification for domestic use?
Hello Martyn Aubrey,
I’m not the CEO of Canoo.
But I knew him from press articles of BMW.
My full Name is Ulrich W.A. Kranz.
Best regards
Ulrich Kranz
Dear Frank Ackland,
Thank you for your reply February 23rd. I have consulted with my investors and they advise against making the information public. But there are options I am considering. One of them could be you sign an NDA because you cannot use the understanding, which I am pretty sure you can’t and have no need of, then using your discretion inform Andrea that the method seems viable with the explanation, the maths and geometry. This is something I am only considering but of course I realize Andrea does not want to sign an NDA, neither would I, as I too would prefer to develop the method myself and who’s to say maybe he will but without knowing the contents of an NDA I do not see how someone can make such an important decision. As I have previously stated nothing gained nothing lost. I do not need any information from Andrea i.e. what the E Cat consists of as I already have a very good idea. All I want to do is put his E Cat into a self sustaining mode so as to produce a constant supply of electricity. Who knows maybe he will achieve success next week, next year or at some future date but there are many people as myself who want this technology to succeed. Obviously, the very last resort will be to ask me how. I should also add that what originally stirred my interest was the remark made by Prof regarding a worldwide organization that I presume is the same one that I was involved with not too long ago. My technology is also controversial and was described as one before its time. Maybe its time has come.
Regards Eric Ashworth.
Sture Andreasson:
I am not yet able to tell when exactly will be made the presentation, but surely it will also be streamed in internet probably live.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Frank Acland:
I can say I am glad of what is going on, albeit much work remains to be done.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Donald G. Chandler:
Before talking of neutrons, I wish I could be sure to know well electrons. I prefer not to put the cart ahead of the horses.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Rossi
Discussion of particle asymmetry here. Neutrons, not electrons, in this case, but maybe still of interest.
“Neutrons are believed to be slightly asymmetrical in shape, being slightly positive at one end and slightly negative at the other — a bit like the electrical equivalent of a bar magnet. “
Kind Regards
Donald Chandler
Dear Andrea,
How has the E-Cat SKL been performing in recent days?
Thank you very much,
Frank Acland
Dear Andrea Rossi,
Will the demonstration start in Stockholm during mars, and then going on several weeks?
Can we see the start at internet, and then follow the demonstration there?
Best Regards
Sture Andreasson
Sweden
Lotr Mileikowsky:
Thank you for your suggestion.
Answer: it is possible to concentrate the control systems for more Ecats into one control system to be designed on the base of the modules’ combined power.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Ulrich Kranz,
Are you the CEO of the very interesting and impressive start up electric vehicle company Canoo?
My apologies for any confusion.
Kind Regards,
Martyn Aubrey
Martyn Aubrey:
I do not know.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Martyn Aubrey:
Ask him,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
PlasmaFan:
Thank you for the information. My answer is: no.
When you see theories that have no link with my paper
http://www.researchgate.net/publication/330601653_E-Cat_SK_and_long_range_particle_interactions
it is very difficult it has to do with the plasma of the E-Cat SK or SKL, because in this paper we put all the possible leads to a theoretical explication of the effect obtained by the Ecat.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Hello Andrea,
Does using diamond coated electrodes that can be embedded with hydrogen atoms from the plasma to produce a Negative Electron Affinity improve the performance of your plasma based E-Cats?
Here is a paper that discusses the process.
https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1910/1910.05158.pdf
Dear Dr Rossi,
Maybe not the same guy, but it would be good if he was.
Warm Regards,
Martyn Aubrey
Dear Dr Rossi,
I wondered if you knew that Ulrich Kranz is the CEO of Canoo, a manufacturer of very advanced electric vehicles, expecting to launch leasing of EVs next year.
https://automobilityla.com/speaker/ulrich-kranz/
https://techcrunch.com/2020/02/11/hyundai-taps-ev-startup-canoo-to-develop-electric-vehicles/
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/canoo-unveils-worlds-first-subscription-only-electric-vehicle-300924748.html
https://www.canoo.com/
This could be a match made in heaven for the Ecat SKL.
Automotive Regards,
Martyn Aubrey
Dear Dr. Rossi,
as computer control module for sure play role in manufacturing price and end price for customers, I have such query:
Every one E-Cat SKL module need own one electronic control module or is it posssible to control for example 4 E-Cat SKLs with 4 core ARM CPU control module?
For future presentation style of E-Cat SKL I propose such old idea (beside the more scientific water shower calorimetry):
E-Cat SKL powering aeromodeller grade electromotor equipped with aeromodeller propeller, behind it a small pole with a few fluttering ribbons in airflow. This whole set on cart with wheels as proof there is no hidden cables from ground.
Best Regards
Anonymous:
DC
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Julio:
Maybe, we are also thinking about that.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Xavier Pitz:
He,he,he,he
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
Regarding your answer “H=F” to Kranz, I’m afraid that you are 21% short of the power output required to get a 5th slot for your picture on top of Dr Brown’s fireplace insert :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f-77xulkB_U&t=36s 🙂
Best Regards,
Xavier Pitz
Dr Rossi:
Are you thinking to sell also by internet the Ecats ?
Is the electricity that exits the plasma DC or AC ?
KeithT:
Maybe.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
In your paper you have explained theoretical mechanisms, in future papers you may update and expand on these mechanisms based on results of E-Cat testing. Is it possible in future papers that you can make predictions that could be detected or suggest specific tests that interested physicists can construct without using E-Cat technology that would aid in the conformation of theory.
Regards,
Keith Thomson.
CC
Correct.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Anonymous:
Yes
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Kranz:
A yes
B,C,D,F you can combine as much modules as you need
G no
H = F
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Sam:
Thank you for the link,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Hello DR Rossi
Scientists create new material.
https://phys.org/news/2020-02-scientists-material-electronics-future.html
Regards
Sam
Dear Andrea,
About the usage of the ECAT-SKL some questions:
A – Is it possible to make a 1 MW power station from a large number of ECAT SKl units?
B – Is it possible to combine 1 MW ECAT SKL power stations to larger units with the Power of C-F?
C – 100 MW?
D – 300 MW?
E – 500 MW?
F – 1000 MW?
G – Ort is has you planned to create a SKL given turbine for such amounts?
H – What will be the largest power of combined ECAT SKL
Ulrich W. A. Kranz
ulrich@ulrich-kranz.de
Mr Andrea Rossi,
in the video in
http://www.ecatskdemo.com
the plasma appears to be composed by different zones with different characteristics: are you extracting electricity separately from different zones ?
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi,
Thank you for your publication
http://www.researchgate.net/publication/330601653_E-Cat_SK_and_long_range_particle_interactions
wherein appears clearly how you obtain a gain of energy without necessity of nuclear reactions, entering in a field in which the second principle of thermodynamic is not applicable, as well as it is not applicable in the field of the catalyzers.
All the best,
CC
WaltC:
What will be done during the presentation has not been defined yet.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Sarah Waldhof:
You read very superficially what I write. If you read with a minimum of intelligence, you can see that I wrote that the noise from the plasma cannot be heard directly by the ears, but can be heard with a stethoscope. When I wrote “never” answering your first comment, I was talking of acoustic pollution, as your first comment was clearly intending, not of stethoscopes. After the second comment of you, it appears a bit malicious that you did not specify in your first comment “can the noise from the plasma be heard by a stethoscope ?”: in this case the answer would have been “yes”.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Plasma ? Your last answer to ma question “Since when does plasma make noise” was “Never”.
And now You say, the plasma makes the noise?
Please excuse me, sir, but this makes no sense.
Can You go into details ?
Regards
Sarah
Dr. Rossi,
Would it be possible for the independent tester(s) to provide a report for the ECat-SKL presentation certifying that the device operated for (X) weeks, producing (Y) KWH of electricity while consuming (Z) KWH of electricity (where (Z) could be zero)?
Best Wishes,
WaltC
Sarah Waldhof:
The plasma. It makes sounds that have a too low level of decibells to be heared directly by ears, but with stethoscope we can receive important information.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Kranz:
Thank you for your insight.
The numbers you give are a supposition. The real numbers will be given during the presentation.
Answers:
A- this depends from the situations
B- I do not know
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Angelo V.:
Yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
KeithT:
There still is a catalyzer.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Ville Kanninen:
Thank you for the information. Maybe some of our Readers is interested to it.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Mr. Inventor
Helsinki city has just launched a global competition called the Helsinki Energy Challenge. The winning proposal will be given one million euro prize.
Here is some introduction text copied from the Helsinki Energy Challenge web site https://energychallenge.hel.fi/
—————–
Currently, more than half of the city’s heat is produced with coal. In order to achieve carbon-neutrality, we need radically new solutions to meet Helsinki’s heat demand. And we are not alone. To fight climate change, sustainable heating solutions are needed in cities all over the world. Heating not just beyond coal, but also beyond burning biomass.
That is why we are launching the Helsinki Energy Challenge.
A global one-million-euro challenge competition to answer the question: How can we decarbonise the heating of Helsinki, using as little biomass as possible?
—————–
I think your company could make the winning proposal.
kind regards
Ville Kanninen
Dear Andrea,
It is now over 9 years since you introduced the E-Cat, the Energy Catalyzer, in your current devices is there still something with a catalytic function or is the name catalyzer now just part of the E-Cat history.
Regards,
Keith Thomson.
Dear Andrea,
will the presentation of ECAT SKL be scheduled only after the end of the ongoing independent test?
Best wishes,
A.V.
Dear Andrea,
given the ECAT SKL has a volume of 10*10*7 cm and a power of 0,7 kWel and 0,3 kWth.
The combination of an ECAT SKL with an infrared heater panel with 700 W power consumption could a product for heating homes and offices. The 300 Wth would be an advantage.
The ECAT SKL could mounted backside the panel with the AI controller and a starter battery.
Despite the cost for electricity for the panel, in Germany and Austria are old and new houses are changing their oil/gas heating to infrared heater panels.
An advantage is the fast heating up of the panels and the good ability to control them.
Sure a prerequisite to use the ECAT SKL, is a certification for domestic use.
My questions:
A – Is it possible to mount an ECAT SKL backside the panel with the AI controller and a starter battery?
B – How long will it last to get a certification for domestic use?
With my best regards
Ulrich Kranz
Ok, the issue is again “confidential”. I could have expected this answer.
But maybe You can INDICATE, WHAT makes the sound, You are analyzing ?
Regards
Sam:
The lack of a cristal ball forbids me to see in the future to detect future insurgence of new problems, if any.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Ahmad Perreira:
Just air, no additives,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Vernie Saens:
Yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.