Mi chiedo perchè Levi abbia scritto una cosa così banale.
Ho letto il documento e mi pare veramente superficiale considerando
il livello dello stesso Levi e che il documento verrà certamente letto
da fisici ed ingegneri.
Ho letto pure le tue controdeduzioni che penso siano più che ragionevoli
e tecnicamente ineccepibili. Non si poteva scrivere altro.
Mi domando solo perchè, un accademico come Levi, abbia potuto
scrivere una missiva simile.
Grazie e continui senza mai mollare.
Arriveranno certamente altre “bordate”.
English synopsis:
The Erratum signed by Prof Levi does not belong to his scientific level and language.
Your answers are correct.
Just continue your work and just ignore the trolls, as you always did
During the test, the wattmeter upstream the power supply did not indicate a significant differential value between Ecat in operation and Ecat disconnected.
This, considering the resolution of the instrument, allows us to state that the consumption of the Ecat was certainly less than 1 watt.
At this point, ANY power greater than 1 watt dissipated by the load resistor would indicate a COP> 1.
And there was a lot of power! According to different types of calculations, also considering the power dissipated by the conductors between the resistance and Ecat, it ranges from about 90 watts to about 200 watts. It’s a monstrous COP!
It is therefore absurd to want to measure the resistance value with 4 wires to ensure an accuracy of one hundredth of an ohm!
But what is it for? Even if you are very, very wrong in the resistance calculations, the dissipated power is there and the COP is and remains very very high with any type of error.
The Erratum has paradoxically confirmed that the Ecat works.
Koen Vandewalle:
I never respond to the trolls, but in this case to respond was necessary, due to the fact that in this case a troll had infiltrated the UNIBO, taking advantage of somebody that, for some reason, had fallen respectfully in love with him.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
The most perplexed thing is the passage directly to the electric, what happened to heat. Produce electricity directly! A discovery that has the flavor of the “Quantum Jump”
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi:
Your response to the Erratum is very convincing and consolidates the credibility of the measurements made by Prof Levi. Clearly the Erratum has been written by a person that has a poor education in Physics, which makes obvious that Prof. Levi has been forced to sign it against his will.
All the best,
Roberto
I don’t quite understand why you write two serious pages in response to the so-called erratum which I believe is either meant as a joke or as a middle finger. In my opinion, that middle finger is certainly not aimed at you, but at the jealous pseudo-critics.
In every secondary school, technical students learn about Wheatstone’s bridge, how strain gauges work and how to connect a Pt-100 temperature sensor.
Except for the sake of a historical friendship, I don’t really understand why you need a college professor to do electrical engineering measurements.
I long to get my ECAT-SKLeps, and in the meantime the natural gas is still burning in my boiler.
In March I don’t have enough money left over to order additional ECAT SKLeps. I hope April will be a slightly more fruitful month. Then I certainly don’t have to buy natural gas anymore.
I wonder weather Ecap Sklep would be classified as a Zero-Emission Energy Source. If got from an American National Institution, it could help to obtain a status of a renewable energy source in EU. If granted, block of SKleps (e.g. 14-20 pcs.) could replace solar generator 10-15 kWp, assuming battery operation. For the moment, discussions with state regulators are difficult as LENR is a book with seven seals.
Sure, one needs pulverized nickel to make it. It should not, however, be an obstacle as the metal is aboundant on Earth, even if it is much more expensive as before.
Dear Andrea,
From a comment published today on http://www.e-catworld.com
I learnt that the troll that has written the Erratum that Levi has been forced to sign is Dewey Weaver. Therefore he is the person acting as the avatar “Fred Zoepfl”, and he is the guy that accessed as a “colleague” the Prof. Credi, the boss of UNIBO that “Zoepfl” has exposed in the emails he sent to several journalists ( like me ), attaching the papers between you and UNIBO supposed to be under NDA. I forwarded to your address copy of these emails that “Zoepfl” mailed to us, so you can understand the whole story.
Do not worry: just a bunch of clowns, that will be annihilated by the distribution of the Ecats. Please do not lose other time to make tests before having your masterpiece out in the market. Do not feed the trolls.
Ad Majora
Anonymous
Bill Conley:
Our orders collection is proceeding well, notwithstanding the fact that several big buyers have been cancelled because didn’t give us the necessary proof of funds.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Frank Acland:
Important question.
We are manufacturing only components of the SKLeps to gain time, because to mass manufacturing the complete units we need to collect an amount of ordered units in the order of magnitude of one million modules. But we are going in the right direction. Today we collected orders for roughly 25000 units, probably as a reaction to the Erratum and our response: as a matter of fact, if you read it well, the erratum paradoxically reinforces the measurements in our favor.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
I was pleased to hear that you that further demonstrations will not be required as “The real tests will be made soon by hundreds of thousands of Ecat SKLeps used by our Clients.”
Does this mean that you are now committed to proceed with SKLep production and deliveries despite not having reached the 1 million order threshold yet?
Thank you kindly for your reply and God’s speed on this critical work.
Albert Ellul:
Elluluya ! You got the core of the issue. The real tests will be made soon by hundreds of thousands of Ecat SKLeps used by our Clients. In fact I decided not to lose more of my time with all this mumbo-jumbo. The real battle is to deliver, all the rest, at this point, is a loss of time.
Elluluya !
Warm Regards,
A.R.
About the claim by the University of two Bologna University gentlemen: Their claim, immaterial of whether they are right or wrong is IRRELEVANT. What matters is whether the ECat SKLep works, or not. We will soon find out. As the Chinese saying goes, it doesn’t matter what colour the cat is as long as it catches the mouse.
Pepito Agresti:
I agree: Bologna is a very beautiful city and I can’t forget the work I made with the immense Prof. Sergio Focardi, Prof emeritus of the Alma Mater.
No further comments, so far.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi,
The signature of the Erratum of Prof Levi has clearly been extorted: the language is different from the language of the original report and the content makes no sense at all and has clearly been written in bad faith for some reason by some scientifically incompetent boss : your answer is perfect. I hope this stuff is not going to disturb your work. That’s all that counts.
By the way, I ordered 3 more Ecat SKLeps after reading the Erratum.
Best,
CC
I just have read the ugly story with the errated report of Levi of university of Bologna. It’s very sad that an even important university like the university of Bologna make this ugly actions into your invention. I’m Italian and so I’m really disappointend with their behaviour. Bologna is a very beautiful city…
Wishes, Pepito
You may recall that I posted in the JONP a detailed analysis of the published measurement values.
With regards to the claim that the temperature of the bath may have caused an increase in the load resistance, the published value of the load resistor was 1.0 Ohm. With the oil bath temperature “slightly superior” to room temperature (assume herein +10 deg K over the previously measured resistance at room temperature), and a thermal coefficient of 100 ppm / K deg, the load resistance would have changed from 1.0 Ohm to 1.001 Ohm. While different, the effect on the power dissipated is very small. Recall P = V**2/R.
Recall my analysis showed:
Power Output of SKLep Nominal 191.646 Watts
Maximum 256.66875 Watts
Minimal 152.1 Watts
While there could have been techniques employed to improve the accuracy of the measurements (as is always the case), the effect on the Power Generated measurements would not significantly change. The report, as originally published, is sufficiently accurate to “tell the story”.
Frank Acland:
This all was under NDA, but the NDA has been violated, so I had to publish my answer.
For the rest, no comment: the Readers can read erratum and answer and think what they deem just.
I have to focus on my work.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
ECat SKLep primarily produces electrical energy, that much we know. But will it also be hot? If so, how hot is it? Is cooling necessary?
In the image of the ECat SKLep, a copper pipe can be seen at the top. What is the purpose of this pipe?
Mr Rossi,
1- does the Ecat SKLep have a safety certification ?
2- does the Ecat SKLep contain any material dangerous for human health ?
3- are all the materials the Ecat SKLep is composed with materials that you can find in normal apparatuses commonly used in the whole world ?
Thank you if you can answer
Anonymous
Rafal:
1- it has to be experimented
2- the SKLep can exit also with high voltage, putting enough Ecats in series to reach the voltage you want
Warm Regards,
A.R.
With such converter I would be able to connect few ECat SKLep modules (up to 4 I think) to my existing solar inverter.
Currently, I got only one of four DC inputs being occupied by my PV installation. Reason why I need the Dc-to-DC converter is because solar inverter requires input voltage no less then 200VDC, typically it is around 400VDC.
Benefit of such solution is that I will avoid possible problems with second AC source in my home (ex. problems with anti-islanding protection, AC overvoltage or grid frequency synchronisation).
Do you think this DC converter would work with Ecat SKLep?
Any idea of having Ecat SKLep with high DC voltage as output?
Regarding usage of Ecat SKLep with on-grid connectivity at home (ex. with anty-islanding protection and able to synchronise AC with grid frequency). I wonder if Ecat SKLep will be compatible with these. My main concern is if MPPT function would work properly with your product: https://www.inverter.com/micro-inverter
I found this video about “gravity” very interesting, and it may well be interesting to other readers : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRr1kaXKBsU
(I hope that one day, Derek Muller, the host from the channel Veritasium will be able to make a video about the Rossi Effect, allowing more people to get some basic understanding about it)
People have been writing tirelessly, yet unsuccessfully, to wear you down and get you to start delivering the SKLep before you have achieved your goal of 1 million SKLeps ordered. Do you think maybe a little sandpaper might help? Keep your spirit up and may you stay healthy and productive.
Art B:
1. we have atarted to manufacture some basic components
2. yes
3. if the big buyers combined are able to pre-order 1 million units and give us real proof to have the funds necessary to pay them at the delivery, contingent with a successful test to be performed before the payment, yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Svein H. Vormedal:
1. we will supply this consulting service to our Clients just before the delivery. The answer depends on the specific situations
2. see 1
3. depends on the situations
4. we cannot know, it depends on the situation and the local regulations
5. a certified professional installer yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
BOB:
Yes
Warm Regards,
A.R.
As a rule, several E-Cat are connected in series or parallel. Is a pin provided to indicate the failure or defect of the E-Cat?
Buonasera Andrea.
Mi chiedo perchè Levi abbia scritto una cosa così banale.
Ho letto il documento e mi pare veramente superficiale considerando
il livello dello stesso Levi e che il documento verrà certamente letto
da fisici ed ingegneri.
Ho letto pure le tue controdeduzioni che penso siano più che ragionevoli
e tecnicamente ineccepibili. Non si poteva scrivere altro.
Mi domando solo perchè, un accademico come Levi, abbia potuto
scrivere una missiva simile.
Grazie e continui senza mai mollare.
Arriveranno certamente altre “bordate”.
English synopsis:
The Erratum signed by Prof Levi does not belong to his scientific level and language.
Your answers are correct.
Just continue your work and just ignore the trolls, as you always did
Dear Andrea
1. Is there a length limit to the cord connecting the controller to the ecat sklep?
2. Can the ecat sklep operate in an outdoor location?
3. Is it better for the controller and the ecat sklep to be inside?
As always
Thanks for your work and attention to questions.
Bob Belovich
Dear Dr. Rossi,
The facts are extremely simple.
During the test, the wattmeter upstream the power supply did not indicate a significant differential value between Ecat in operation and Ecat disconnected.
This, considering the resolution of the instrument, allows us to state that the consumption of the Ecat was certainly less than 1 watt.
At this point, ANY power greater than 1 watt dissipated by the load resistor would indicate a COP> 1.
And there was a lot of power! According to different types of calculations, also considering the power dissipated by the conductors between the resistance and Ecat, it ranges from about 90 watts to about 200 watts. It’s a monstrous COP!
It is therefore absurd to want to measure the resistance value with 4 wires to ensure an accuracy of one hundredth of an ohm!
But what is it for? Even if you are very, very wrong in the resistance calculations, the dissipated power is there and the COP is and remains very very high with any type of error.
The Erratum has paradoxically confirmed that the Ecat works.
Kind Regards,
Italo R.
Koen Vandewalle:
I never respond to the trolls, but in this case to respond was necessary, due to the fact that in this case a troll had infiltrated the UNIBO, taking advantage of somebody that, for some reason, had fallen respectfully in love with him.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Roberto:
Thank you for your opinion,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Camillo Urbani:
As I said, the lack of heat is a feature of our technology. Theoretical bases have been put in the paper
http://www.researchgate.net/publication/330601653_E-Cat_SK_and_long_range_particle_interactions
Warm Regards,
A.R.
The most perplexed thing is the passage directly to the electric, what happened to heat. Produce electricity directly! A discovery that has the flavor of the “Quantum Jump”
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi:
Your response to the Erratum is very convincing and consolidates the credibility of the measurements made by Prof Levi. Clearly the Erratum has been written by a person that has a poor education in Physics, which makes obvious that Prof. Levi has been forced to sign it against his will.
All the best,
Roberto
I don’t quite understand why you write two serious pages in response to the so-called erratum which I believe is either meant as a joke or as a middle finger. In my opinion, that middle finger is certainly not aimed at you, but at the jealous pseudo-critics.
In every secondary school, technical students learn about Wheatstone’s bridge, how strain gauges work and how to connect a Pt-100 temperature sensor.
Except for the sake of a historical friendship, I don’t really understand why you need a college professor to do electrical engineering measurements.
I long to get my ECAT-SKLeps, and in the meantime the natural gas is still burning in my boiler.
In March I don’t have enough money left over to order additional ECAT SKLeps. I hope April will be a slightly more fruitful month. Then I certainly don’t have to buy natural gas anymore.
Regards,
Koen
Peter Tomaszewski:
The Ecat SKLep does not belong to the LENR cathegory.
Thank you for your suggestion, though.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
I wonder weather Ecap Sklep would be classified as a Zero-Emission Energy Source. If got from an American National Institution, it could help to obtain a status of a renewable energy source in EU. If granted, block of SKleps (e.g. 14-20 pcs.) could replace solar generator 10-15 kWp, assuming battery operation. For the moment, discussions with state regulators are difficult as LENR is a book with seven seals.
Sure, one needs pulverized nickel to make it. It should not, however, be an obstacle as the metal is aboundant on Earth, even if it is much more expensive as before.
Anonymous:
One thing is sure: the next tests will be only made by our Clients when we will deliver.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
From a comment published today on
http://www.e-catworld.com
I learnt that the troll that has written the Erratum that Levi has been forced to sign is Dewey Weaver. Therefore he is the person acting as the avatar “Fred Zoepfl”, and he is the guy that accessed as a “colleague” the Prof. Credi, the boss of UNIBO that “Zoepfl” has exposed in the emails he sent to several journalists ( like me ), attaching the papers between you and UNIBO supposed to be under NDA. I forwarded to your address copy of these emails that “Zoepfl” mailed to us, so you can understand the whole story.
Do not worry: just a bunch of clowns, that will be annihilated by the distribution of the Ecats. Please do not lose other time to make tests before having your masterpiece out in the market. Do not feed the trolls.
Ad Majora
Anonymous
Bill Conley:
Our orders collection is proceeding well, notwithstanding the fact that several big buyers have been cancelled because didn’t give us the necessary proof of funds.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Frank Acland:
Important question.
We are manufacturing only components of the SKLeps to gain time, because to mass manufacturing the complete units we need to collect an amount of ordered units in the order of magnitude of one million modules. But we are going in the right direction. Today we collected orders for roughly 25000 units, probably as a reaction to the Erratum and our response: as a matter of fact, if you read it well, the erratum paradoxically reinforces the measurements in our favor.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
I was pleased to hear that you that further demonstrations will not be required as “The real tests will be made soon by hundreds of thousands of Ecat SKLeps used by our Clients.”
Does this mean that you are now committed to proceed with SKLep production and deliveries despite not having reached the 1 million order threshold yet?
Thank you kindly for your reply and God’s speed on this critical work.
Bill
Albert Ellul:
Elluluya ! You got the core of the issue. The real tests will be made soon by hundreds of thousands of Ecat SKLeps used by our Clients. In fact I decided not to lose more of my time with all this mumbo-jumbo. The real battle is to deliver, all the rest, at this point, is a loss of time.
Elluluya !
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr. Rossi,
About the claim by the University of two Bologna University gentlemen: Their claim, immaterial of whether they are right or wrong is IRRELEVANT. What matters is whether the ECat SKLep works, or not. We will soon find out. As the Chinese saying goes, it doesn’t matter what colour the cat is as long as it catches the mouse.
Dear Andrea,
You have stated recently that you have started the manufacturing of the SKLeps. So far, does this mean you have been manufacturing:
a) Only components for the SKLeps
b) Completed SKLeps
c) Both
Many thanks,
Frank Acland
Pepito Agresti:
I agree: Bologna is a very beautiful city and I can’t forget the work I made with the immense Prof. Sergio Focardi, Prof emeritus of the Alma Mater.
No further comments, so far.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
CC:
Thank you for your insight and support,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Dr Andrea Rossi,
The signature of the Erratum of Prof Levi has clearly been extorted: the language is different from the language of the original report and the content makes no sense at all and has clearly been written in bad faith for some reason by some scientifically incompetent boss : your answer is perfect. I hope this stuff is not going to disturb your work. That’s all that counts.
By the way, I ordered 3 more Ecat SKLeps after reading the Erratum.
Best,
CC
I just have read the ugly story with the errated report of Levi of university of Bologna. It’s very sad that an even important university like the university of Bologna make this ugly actions into your invention. I’m Italian and so I’m really disappointend with their behaviour. Bologna is a very beautiful city…
Wishes, Pepito
Steven Nicholes Karels:
Thank you for your insight,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea Rossi,
You may recall that I posted in the JONP a detailed analysis of the published measurement values.
With regards to the claim that the temperature of the bath may have caused an increase in the load resistance, the published value of the load resistor was 1.0 Ohm. With the oil bath temperature “slightly superior” to room temperature (assume herein +10 deg K over the previously measured resistance at room temperature), and a thermal coefficient of 100 ppm / K deg, the load resistance would have changed from 1.0 Ohm to 1.001 Ohm. While different, the effect on the power dissipated is very small. Recall P = V**2/R.
Recall my analysis showed:
Power Output of SKLep Nominal 191.646 Watts
Maximum 256.66875 Watts
Minimal 152.1 Watts
While there could have been techniques employed to improve the accuracy of the measurements (as is always the case), the effect on the Power Generated measurements would not significantly change. The report, as originally published, is sufficiently accurate to “tell the story”.
Frank Acland:
This all was under NDA, but the NDA has been violated, so I had to publish my answer.
For the rest, no comment: the Readers can read erratum and answer and think what they deem just.
I have to focus on my work.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Dear Andrea,
Can you make any comment on these documents?
https://e-catworld.com/2022/03/28/giueseppe-levi-erratum-and-andrea-rossi-response/
Kind regards,
Frank Acland
Roffi:
The heat is irrelevant.
The copper nut is the trimmer.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Hello Dottore Rossi,
ECat SKLep primarily produces electrical energy, that much we know. But will it also be hot? If so, how hot is it? Is cooling necessary?
In the image of the ECat SKLep, a copper pipe can be seen at the top. What is the purpose of this pipe?
Best wishes.
Roffi
Anonymous:
1- yes
2- no
3- yes; besides, all the components are safety certified
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Mr Rossi,
1- does the Ecat SKLep have a safety certification ?
2- does the Ecat SKLep contain any material dangerous for human health ?
3- are all the materials the Ecat SKLep is composed with materials that you can find in normal apparatuses commonly used in the whole world ?
Thank you if you can answer
Anonymous
Robert Dorr:
HE,HE,HE…
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Jitse:
1 premature
2 yes
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Xavier Pitz:
Thank you for the links,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Rafal:
This connection must be made by a certified specialist and depends on the specific situation,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Norma:
Yes
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Rafal:
1- it has to be experimented
2- the SKLep can exit also with high voltage, putting enough Ecats in series to reach the voltage you want
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Hello Dr Rossi,
Another idea is tu use Dc-to-DC converted like this one:
https://www.cnsspele.com/dc-dc-converter/500w-24vdc-to-36-48-64-100-150-200-220-250-300-350-400-500vdc-converter-dc-power-supply
With such converter I would be able to connect few ECat SKLep modules (up to 4 I think) to my existing solar inverter.
Currently, I got only one of four DC inputs being occupied by my PV installation. Reason why I need the Dc-to-DC converter is because solar inverter requires input voltage no less then 200VDC, typically it is around 400VDC.
Benefit of such solution is that I will avoid possible problems with second AC source in my home (ex. problems with anti-islanding protection, AC overvoltage or grid frequency synchronisation).
Do you think this DC converter would work with Ecat SKLep?
Any idea of having Ecat SKLep with high DC voltage as output?
Dr Rossi,
Are you still convinced that by this year you the deliveries of the Ecat SKLep will start ?
Best,
Norma
Regarding usage of Ecat SKLep with on-grid connectivity at home (ex. with anty-islanding protection and able to synchronise AC with grid frequency). I wonder if Ecat SKLep will be compatible with these. My main concern is if MPPT function would work properly with your product:
https://www.inverter.com/micro-inverter
Dear Andrea, CC, DrLG
I found this video about “gravity” very interesting, and it may well be interesting to other readers :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XRr1kaXKBsU
(I hope that one day, Derek Muller, the host from the channel Veritasium will be able to make a video about the Rossi Effect, allowing more people to get some basic understanding about it)
Also talking about gravity it is sometimes not easy in conversations to distinguish “g” from “G”…
https://oxscience.com/difference-between-g-and-g/
Best Regards,
Xavier Pitz
Dear Andrea,
1 The Ecat SK produces a lot of heat for industrial users, what is the current status for use by European customers?
2 Are there any potential results in competition with nuclear power plants, or use in domestic environments?
Sincerely, Jitse
Dear Andrea,
People have been writing tirelessly, yet unsuccessfully, to wear you down and get you to start delivering the SKLep before you have achieved your goal of 1 million SKLeps ordered. Do you think maybe a little sandpaper might help? Keep your spirit up and may you stay healthy and productive.
Sincerely,
Robert Dorr
Art B:
1. we have atarted to manufacture some basic components
2. yes
3. if the big buyers combined are able to pre-order 1 million units and give us real proof to have the funds necessary to pay them at the delivery, contingent with a successful test to be performed before the payment, yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
CC:
No,
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Svein H. Vormedal:
1. we will supply this consulting service to our Clients just before the delivery. The answer depends on the specific situations
2. see 1
3. depends on the situations
4. we cannot know, it depends on the situation and the local regulations
5. a certified professional installer yes.
Warm Regards,
A.R.
Sam:
Thank you for the link,
Warm regards,
A.R.
Hello DR Rossi
This is a lecture by Professor
Andrew Boothroyd. about the
History of Superconductivity
and an explanation on how
it works.
https://youtu.be/NzzchLXdGmE
Another on breakthroughs.
https://youtu.be/i9On9h3CjWw
Regards
Sam